Somebody sent me the link on Tuesday night with no message, just three crying-laughing faces, which is how you know something about your own street has turned up on the internet. By Wednesday it was in every group chat I’m in. So I sat down with a cup of tea and watched all eighty-odd minutes of it.
The video is Rhydyfelin: Edge of the City, Start of the Valleys, from The Central Club. Rhydyfelin got the treatment last week. He filmed on a Friday evening, came back for a second day, and it went up on 22 April.
I’ve lived here long enough to have opinions about it, and so, judging by the comments, has everyone else. Here’s what’s in it, what people are saying, and what I think it got right and wrong.
Who are The Central Club?
The Central Club is a podcast and YouTube channel from Cardiff. Its presenter takes a camera round council estates in South Wales, stops whoever is about, and asks them what the place is really like. The videos are long and unhurried, mostly walking and talking, and the locals do most of the talking. Rhydyfelin is the latest stop.
What’s in the video
It opens on the estate at about seven on a Friday, with the Garth in the background. The presenter’s first point is a fair one: we’re the first stop in the valleys coming up from Cardiff, close enough that our accents are “a bit neutral”. (Several people have since pointed out in the comments that Taff’s Well is technically the first bit of Rhondda Cynon Taf. They’re right. We’ll let it go.)

The first people he meets give the answer you’d get from most of us: everybody knows everybody, there’s trouble now and again, there are drugs about like everywhere, but it’s tight. One man gives it seven out of ten, and only that low because he doesn’t want too many people moving in. I laughed out loud at that, because it’s exactly the kind of thing people round here say.
Then there’s a long, rambling chat in a back garden with two older men, which wanders from Cardiff (“Little England beyond Wales”) through Owain Glyndŵr to Margaret Thatcher and immigration. More on that below, because it’s the part of the video I’m least comfortable with.
After that, a fish bar at the top shops, a quick pizza, and then the heart of the whole thing: Arthur’s Gym on a busy Friday night. Jamie Arthur, a former Commonwealth gold medallist and Commonwealth professional champion, explains that he put £30,000 of his own money into a burnt-out building, opened it in 2012, and runs it in the evenings after his day job. He isn’t training fighters any more, he says. He’s training people to have better lives. One by one, the lads tell the camera what it’s done for them: confidence, mental health, somewhere to go, people who’ve got their back.
Then one of the teenagers from the gym takes the presenter round the top side after dark. There are smashed windows, a rat, rubbish, flats he says are used by people on crack, and a story or two he probably shouldn’t have told his mam he’d seen. Day two starts at the bottom end by the flats near Hawthorn. A 17-year-old sums up life for his age group in two words I can’t print here, and the presenter signs off with his verdict: seven out of ten, with good parts and bad parts, lots of green, good connections and plenty of takeaways.
What the comments are saying
The comments have been piling up all week, and they’re more thoughtful than YouTube comments have any right to be.
The gym won. By a distance, the most-liked comments are about the lads at Arthur’s: how polite they were, how confident, how they spoke to a stranger with a camera better than most adults would. Relatives have turned up to say how proud they are. One mentions ten years of training there, another their nephew. People who knew Jamie as a young boxer in Cwmbran have chipped in, and someone reckons the world needs more Jamie Arthurs. One person noted, with a straight face, that nobody in the gym swore, which is more than can be said for the rest of the video.


People stuck up for the place. Someone who’s lived here on and off all their life wrote that it’s honestly not as bad as it’s portrayed, and that the drugs are a problem everywhere now, not a Rhydyfelin thing. Another, not from here, described being invited into two homes and fed bread and butter by people they’d only just met. Even the bleakest comment, which called this the land of no dreams, ended by saying that if anything happens, everyone rallies round.


The old memories came out. My favourite was from a 75-year-old who grew up in Dynea, just above us. He remembers prefabs all the way down Brook Street to Hawthorn, when most people worked in the pits, and tickling trout in the brook. Others remembered summers visiting aunties in the 80s. One blamed the right to buy for breaking up the estates, as people sold up and moved on.

Not everyone liked how it was made. A couple of commenters, including a self-described proud Welshman, called out the leading questions and the way casual racism was laughed along with rather than challenged. One pointed out that the older man in the garden asked for a remark to be cut, and it wasn’t.

And everyone has a request. Glyncoch, obviously. Cae Fardre, Ynysybwl, Cilfynydd, Maerdy, Gurnos. Every estate in South Wales apparently wants its turn.
What it got right
More than I expected, honestly. These “estate tour” videos usually go looking for the worst thing on the street and point a camera at it. This one did a bit of that, but it kept noticing something else, and so did the presenter. He says early on that every estate he’s visited, however rough its name, has kids out playing and getting their hands dirty, in a way you don’t often see in the city. That’s true here. On a light evening you can hear them from three streets away.
It also caught the old feud with Glyncoch perfectly. A man in his forties admits he has no idea why the two villages don’t get on, and his own son tells him to ask Granddad. That’s the most Valleys thing I’ve ever seen. Generations of grudges, and nobody can remember what they’re for.
And it found Jamie Arthur. I’d happily have watched an hour of just the gym. What he describes, a place where somebody tells you you’re doing well, is a simple idea and a rare one. Most of us get far more people pointing out what we’ve done wrong than people building us up. The young men on that video are the proof that it works.
What it got wrong, or didn’t look for
The garden conversation is hard to watch. There’s real hurt in it. Here are men who’ve had their heating money cut, who watched the pits and the steelworks close, and who feel that nobody in charge has thought about them in forty years. That deserves to be heard. But the camera kept nudging the conversation towards immigrants, and the worst of what came out, including a line about boats that the speaker himself asked to have cut, isn’t the voice of this village. It’s what you get when you ask an angry man a loaded question and keep filming.
The same goes for the stories about strangers trying to take children from the parks, which three different people repeat in the video. Nobody offers anything more than word of mouth. If you’ve seen something, report it to South Wales Police on 101, or 999 if a child is in danger right now. If you’ve only heard it from someone who heard it from someone, think twice before passing it on. Rumours like that have a way of landing on whoever looks least like everyone else.
And a camera that arrives at seven on a Friday finds what’s loudest at seven on a Friday. It didn’t see the school run, the Taff Trail on a Sunday morning, the people who’ve kept the same allotment for thirty years or the neighbours who put each other’s bins out. It didn’t mention that this was where the first Welsh-medium secondary school in South Wales opened, in 1962. Our history doesn’t make the bad block of flats any better. But a place isn’t its worst corner any more than it’s its best gym. It’s everything in between, most of which is too ordinary to film.
The line I can’t stop thinking about
It isn’t any of the dramatic bits. It’s the 17-year-old at the bottom end, saying there’s nothing to do here for his age and no jobs, with a shrug that tells you he isn’t expecting anyone to argue. It’s echoed by the 16-year-old at the fish bar, who says that if you’re not in a football team, it’s easy to end up with the wrong crowd. One commenter put it well: the place could do with a decent youth club.

We’re good at looking after small children here, and the older generation have each other. The gap is the years in between, when you’re too old for the park and too young for the pub, and if there isn’t a Jamie Arthur in your life, there isn’t much. A lot of the “rough” in the video is really that gap, filmed after dark. If you run something for teenagers in Rhydyfelin, or want to, we’d love to hear about it and add it to our community activities and sports guides.
So, seven out of ten?
I’d take it. It’s a fair mark from a man from Cardiff who spent two evenings here, and probably about what most of us would give it on a wet Tuesday. Rhydyfelin is a place you can see the sea from on a clear day, if you climb high enough, and a place where the cheapest flats need far more care than they get. Both are true, and the video, to its credit, mostly lets them be.
Watch it if you live here. You’ll wince a couple of times, and you’ll probably recognise someone. Then, if you’ve been meaning to get fit, go down to Arthur’s. Jamie says it’s Monday, Wednesday and Friday from half six, and everyone’s welcome.



